Regresar a la lista
On the Road Again

On the Road Again

4.009 60
0
Gerry R. Dagonese

Gerry R. Dagonese


Free Account, Highland, CA

Comentarios 60

  • Heribert Fischer

    Heribert Fischer 19/06/2007 19:06

    great shot. like it
    regards Heribert
    Me gusta
  • Gerry R. Dagonese

    Gerry R. Dagonese 22/04/2007 0:58

    First of all, a thank you to Stefan for proposing. I would also like to give thanks to all who participated in the voting, and whether pro or contra, especially to those who left comments.

    Gerry
    Me gusta
  • CsomorLászló

    CsomorLászló 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    100!
    Congrat!
    CsL
  • Dennis Maloney

    Dennis Maloney 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    There is only one little thing that bothers me on this and it is the halo look around the left rear of the car....but, the detail, the title and effects are something that I like, and I am voting on my first feelings....pro
  • Renato T.

    Renato T. 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    PRO!
  • PINDORIUS

    PINDORIUS 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    -
  • Pascal Viyer

    Pascal Viyer 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    Sorry PRO
  • Gerry R. Dagonese

    Gerry R. Dagonese 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    Thank you Patrick (and to all who have voted so far),

    You raise some good points. Aside from the headlights (already discussed), I would consider painting the effect into the rear and side windows also at a lower opacity.

    Gerry
  • Oliver Suhr

    Oliver Suhr 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    contra.
  • Ivano Cheli (1)

    Ivano Cheli (1) 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    pro
  • Patrick B. Parenteau

    Patrick B. Parenteau 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    Trying to get clean shots of cars during a street show is very hard to do. You have to deal with reflections, people, wires etc. so a motion filter can work to your advantage if used to its full potential. Lets assume for a second that the filter is acceptable as a creative device in this case - I see two "mistakes", one as pointed out, the blur off the headlights and you missed putting the effect thru the back and side windows. I think your basic idea works great for this "rod", but you need to finish the job. Contra (for now)
  • Gerry R. Dagonese

    Gerry R. Dagonese 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    Hi Andy,

    Thanks again for the time to look and study, and return to look again; thank you for the comment. We all benefit from the comments. Most of all, thank you for yours to Stefan; your act displayed character.

    I think the reason for the effect would dictate where it was placed, to what parts of the photo, and whether it was a "mistake." Just like the decision to leave parts of the car in the effect (i.e., the tail end), the decision to leave the effect on the light was intentional. Indeed, in the post-processing stages, I had removed the effect from the light. But, because I liked it better with the rays running from the light, and because I felt it was within the context of my intent (the car emerging into existence not necessarily all at one time), I painted it back into the picture. At the same time, I decreased the opacity on this part of the shot so the light has slightly less the effect.

    I appreciate the comment and the opinion being expressed. Without that, we do not always have the opportunity to see what went into creating a work, and in the process, learn--both as the photographer and the viewers.

    Gerry
  • ivano cheli (2)

    ivano cheli (2) 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    +++
  • Andy Pomplun

    Andy Pomplun 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    btw, I now found the mistake on your photo: it is that the filter goes off the headlight on the left as well and this is the most disturbing there, the effect should only go around the outlines of the object... :)))
  • Andy Pomplun

    Andy Pomplun 22/04/2007 0:47 Comentario de la votación

    I am sorry Gerry, and I sure hope you don't mind me making this OFF-TOPIC comment here. And I am doing so because of Stefan and because he's told me you wouldn't mind:
    I would officially like to apologize to Stefan Mosley if I should have insulted him by not having been able to contact him before deleting his comment.

    But to make it clear once more, I am not apologizing for having done so, I just never wanted to hurt anybody's feelings. I would have done so in any other case as well and I will do so again every time I get the impression that comments strive off from the topic and are offending others directly in a way we will not tolerate. We do want discussions about photography, and we are all very glad when members wirte their why and why nots here.

    We expect everybody to do so in a polite way though!!
    We expect furthermore that the discussions sticks with the subject and does not go off towards other members, their own works or abilities.... You get the meaning? :)

    And now, I would be glad if we could go to the topic again, and that is voting on Gerry's image here, please

    NO MORE OFF TOPIC COMMENTS NOW!

    Happy voting :)

    Andy
Propuesta para la Galería

Etiqueta

critique - straight and tough cars subjects

Más fotos de Gerry R. Dagonese

Información

Sección Subjects: Critique - straight and tough
Carpeta Cars
Vistas 4.009
Publicada
idioma
Licencia